Pro guide Fabien Caterina chasing native trout near Tynset, Norway. Photo by Julien Pouille
The Sharp End
With research piling up showing fish feel pain, one angler takes on the moral and ethical calculus of continuing to cast
I’d been an angler for more than two decades when I caught the strangest fish I’d ever seen, a fish that led me down a path of questioning whether I even should have picked up a fishing rod in the first place. I was fishing my favorite Northern California trout stream, a ribbon of deep turquoise fifteen yards wide that babbles between banks of slick, grapefruit-sized cobbles of granite, the indomitable hulk of Mount Shasta looming far up-current, a snowy pyramid above the pines.
There hadn’t been much of an insect hatch that afternoon, so I’d spent the hot hours swinging in a streamside hammock I tied between two trees, half-heartedly reading a Larry McMurtry novel and watching the water roll past. Finally, as the sun set, the trout began their habitual evening rise to the surface. I waded to my waist in the ice-cold water, tied an all-purpose size-16 Parachute Adams fly to my whisker-thin leader, and began looping tight casts upstream
2,300 words to go
You’re just getting to the good part.
This story — and 42 issues of them — opens with a subscription.
Either one picks up right where you left off.
Join 7,000+ readers · Independently owned · Since 2008
Already a subscriber? Sign in
Adventure Journal — Print Quarterly
Stories like this, in your hands four times a year.
42 issues. 11 years. Independently owned. Printed on 70lb uncoated paper with a soft-touch cover, solar-powered, and shipped in a brown paper envelope. Free domestic shipping.